I just finished reading this manga yesterday and the anime two days before, I was intrigued by this series so I decided to read the manga. Honestly, I only watched this because of the fanservice but then when I finally got to watch, the fanservice is really there but I like the humor more. I can’t seem to ship anyone in the anime yeah and it kinda bug me. But when I started reading the manga I thought that Lulu and Aya would make a good ship, as well as Kengo and Akira since Akira seems to be all tsundere for Kengo, but I guess my main pair would be Shisui and Homurabi. Yeah, even when I didn’t see them interact my fangirl senses tells me to ship them. Okay, I will stop yapping about ships and proceed to the true purpose of this post that is to comment about Monochrome Factor.
Anime:
I see no point although the plot twist was kinda interesting. Their killing of kokuchis kinda reminds me of hollows from bleach. Their fight with those creatures of darkness is only focused inside their circle and not to other people they don’t interact with so I think in this aspect it kinda lacks the scope element because you don’t feel that the world is indeed in danger because bad happenings only happen to people who are close to the main characters.
I think that the fanservice doesn’t bring that much feels. And that I hate the fact that they always pick on Kengo being stupid and all but I think he’s a lovable character (so much lovable not Akira).
It’s too different from the manga but I understand the part where they chose to postpone Homurabi’s cameo (since he is the antagonist and all).
I like discrete gays, those kind of gays that are the exact opposite of Shirogane in the anime, I like his voice and his true self but whenever he teases Akira it kinda irks me off.
Manga:
The manga is very different from the anime. The plot has loopholes and is not well established unlike most of the mangas I’ve read. Furthermore, I think it is all over the place and like most of the reviews, I think that the later chapters of the series is very confusing and can’t be reconciled. -.- Like for example, Homurabi at first acts like wants to become the tyrant of the shadow and the light realms which they—kings keep in tune with each other and then the next thing we know he also wants to keep the shadow realm from expanding into the light realm to the point of sealing some of the shadows in his own body. Another is his attitude towards Shisui, first he becomes so angry at him and probably one could contemplate about how he would continue hating Shisui for being irresponsible but then the next thing he does is to stop Shirogane and Ryuuko from replacing Shisui as his counterpart. I don’t even understand how we was able to be so attached to Shisui (I agree that the guy is so lovable and all) but to think that he was angry at the guy and I think he was the first guy who made Homurabi snap. If it was love at fist sight or something, then probably Homurabi planned it all along. The fast pace of him garnering children which resulted to the imbalance and making Shisui lecture him. I guess, he didn’t expect Shirogane and Ryuuko to think about replacing Shisui because of his slow pace in choosing his children.
I thought about Homurabi’s action and I can’t help thinking that his reason was so stupid and so immature. He’s a king, he should think rationally. I think Ryuuko’s death was in vain, he was killed for no reason so as the case of Kengo which really pissed me off.
I really think Homurabi is hopelessly in love with Shisui. But I can’t comprehend why the mangaka came up with such a lame reason for trying to plunge the earth into darkness. But come to think of it, -.- I think Homurabi never thought of something like that, I think he was misunderstood from the very beginning, BUT I don’t understand why he had to kill Ryuuko and Kengo. I don’t understand why he wanted the shadow factor for himself as well as Ryuuko’s inshi. What’s he going to do with it, it’s not like he could make Shisui his queen or something.
As for Shisui, he is too kind/stupid for accepting that kind of response from Homurabi. So far, the most rational character is Shirogane, he always uses his common sense to deal with things. He thinks about the right thing to do, but I guess I thought he was an asshole when he was trying to force Akira on giving him the inshi that could’ve saved kengo!
Now as for Kengo, I Love him, he’s my favorite character. He’s kind and understanding but he’s not appreciated well enough, he’s always the underdog, and he’s never risen from the position. Like other sentiments I’ve read on the net, I hated the part when Kengo died. From the beginning, Sorano presented how much potential Kengo has which makes you think that he doesn’t deserve all the bullying and stuff, he’s even supposed to be the next direct king of shin right?
What I really hated about that part was when it was as though they didn’t care about Kengo’s life. I hated all of them for that, they don’t deserve to live! -.- To think Nanaya and the others were spared but Kengo wasn’t, isn’t unfair? My sister and I were very angry about this.
To those who liked Kengo, I think they were lamenting about his death and then got their hearts broken by the fact that the characters in the manga didn’t care for their friend as well as the mangaka. It was as though everything was against Kengo. Somehow I felt happy when he was with Ryuuko. I think the people who cared for him was only Sawaki, Mayu, and Ryuuko.
When I saw Kengo’s face when he was going away with Ryuuko, I think somehow he felt relieved. If you’re in his place, always being treated that way, you’ll end up miserable and your self confidence probably would diminish and a lot of bad things will follow. That’s why I hate that part! Tsk. Earlier, when I was riding the bus, I thought about buying the manga and burning it into a crisp. I know it’s a waste of money, but if every I could by one, I think I’m going to do it, for the sake of Kengo. He deserves a good way of dying. -.-
I tried so hard trying to sew through the loopholes of the plot and justify them. In the end, I still end up with “the manga is screwed up”.
The only good thing about this manga is Sawaki X Kou, tsundere Akira, Homurabi X Shisui. Especially the last pair. -.- I was so intrigued by Ryuuko so I’ll add too. I’ll probably delete my copy of this manga later. As for the fanfic I was planning, I still don’t know If I’ll pursue it.